Stability (Eberhart & Russel)      

Comparisons ANOVA Means Summary PDF Output Stability Graph Selection Graph Transformation Plot

BARTLETT's Test for Homogenity of Variances 17.3124 Prob. 0.0039
DEVIATIONS FROM THEIR REGRESSION
VARIETYMeans²VibiSYijIjßi*#YijIjSd²ijF-TestProbabilityR²ProbabilityS²Di
1 COGG -2 67.2444 122.2549 0.853 130.6730 111.5154 10.7395 0.9100 0.4597 0.9122 0.0030 -0.2654
2 COGG -2*ML -267 69.7222 220.6459 1.118 171.2225 191.4630 29.1829 2.4729 0.0467 0.8677 0.0069 4.3455 *
3 COGG -2*PUSA -10 66.1278 126.7920 0.803 122.9582 98.7365 28.0554 2.3774 0.0543 0.7787 0.0199 4.0636
4 COGG -2*RMG -275 68.9000 170.4422 0.922 141.2424 130.2846 40.1576 3.4029 0.0106 0.7644 0.0227 7.0891 *
5 COGG -2*PDM -89 67.8222 163.7660 0.978 149.7596 146.4712 17.2948 1.4655 0.2153 0.8944 0.0043 1.3734
6 COGG -2*LGG -460 70.0667 176.7822 1.010 154.7064 156.3075 20.4748 1.7350 0.1450 0.8842 0.0052 2.1684
7 COGG -2*LGG -410 68.9722 177.2365 0.909 139.1822 126.5117 50.7248 4.2983 0.0025 0.7138 0.0342 9.7309 **
8 COGG -2*COGG -22 68.3389 257.5565 1.055 161.5150 170.3682 87.1883 7.3882 0.0000 0.6615 0.0490 18.8468 ***
9 COGG -2*ML -26 - 69.3000 121.4089 0.878 134.4185 117.9998 3.4091 0.2889 0.8849 0.9719 0.0003 -2.0980
10 COGG -2*PUSA -10 72.0278 316.5966 1.418* 217.1891 308.0628 8.5338 0.7231 0.5774 0.9730 0.0003 -0.8168
11 COGG -2*RMG -275 70.2222 401.7304 1.281 196.1635 251.3041 150.4263 12.7468 0.0000 0.6256 0.0610 34.6563 ***
12 COGG -2*PDM -89 70.7389 201.2742 0.968 148.2334 143.5010 57.7732 4.8956 0.0010 0.7130 0.0344 11.4930 ***
13 ML -267 67.7889 142.1015 0.805 123.3120 99.3056 42.7958 3.6264 0.0074 0.6988 0.0382 7.7487 **
Total 2598.5880 13.000 1990.5760 2051.8310 546.7562

Population Mean 69.0209Std.Err. Mean 1.4501
Bi Mean 1.0000Std.Err. Bi 0.2620
Comparisons Between Different Stability Models
EberhartDev.MS/TAIEcovalence
Varietyand Russel Bi(MSE/R)a Alphal lambadaHanson DiShukla s²Wricke W²
COGG -2 0.853 0.910 -0.149 0.819 3.336 2.360 14.030
COGG -2*ML -267 1.118 2.473 0.120 2.077 6.663 6.447** 31.322
COGG -2*PUSA -105 0.803 2.377 -0.201 2.167 5.297 7.080** 33.996
COGG -2*RMG -275 0.922 3.403 -0.079 3.009 6.507 8.754** 41.078
COGG -2*PDM -89 - 0.978 1.466 -0.022 1.277 4.689 3.149** 17.368
COGG -2*LGG -460 1.010 1.735 0.011 1.500 5.202 3.887** 20.490
COGG -2*LGG -410 0.909 4.298 -0.093 3.814 7.242 11.333** 51.993
COGG -2*COGG -22 1.055 7.388 0.056 6.311 9.844 19.761** 87.647
COGG -2*ML -26 - 7 0.878 0.289 -0.124 0.258 2.065 0.390 5.693
COGG -2*PUSA -105 1.418 0.723 0.426 0.558 8.156 7.397** 35.339
COGG -2*RMG -2753 1.281 12.747 0.286 10.233 13.617 37.459** 162.524
COGG -2*PDM -89 0.968 4.896 -0.033 4.278 7.870 12.736** 57.928
ML -267 0.805 3.626 -0.198 3.303 6.542 10.531** 48.598

ANOVA for Stability ( Days to Flowering )
Source of VariationsdfSum of SquaresMean SquaresF RatioProbability
Rep within Env. 12 85.23060 7.10255 0.675 0.76661
Varieties 12 180.37283 15.03107 1.430 0.18279
Env.+ (Var.* Env.) 65 2598.58765 39.97827 3.802 0.00000 ***
Environments 5 1990.57593 398.11519 37.863 0.00000 ***
Var.* Env. 60 608.01171 10.13353 0.964 0.55711
Environments (Lin.) 1 1990.57593 1990.57593 189.316 0.00000 ***
Var.* Env.(Lin.) 12 61.25554 5.10463 0.485 0.91419
Pooled Deviation 52 546.75616 10.51454 4.037 0.00000 ***
Pooled Error 144 375.01162 2.60425
Total 77 2778.96027 36.09039

Means table for Days to Flowering
VarietyEnv. 1Env. 2Env. 3Env. 4Env. 5Env. 6Gen.µS²DiRankbiRank
ACOGG -2 59.533 64.400 65.400 71.200 71.467 71.467 67.244 -0.265 1 0.853 9
BCOGG -2*ML -267 61.667 65.000 65.267 75.333 72.833 78.233 69.722 4.345 7 1.118 7
CCOGG -2*PUSA -1 60.600 63.933 63.967 63.667 73.800 70.800 66.128 4.064 6 0.803 11
DCOGG -2*RMG -27 62.333 66.800 64.200 70.667 78.600 70.800 68.900 7.089 8 0.922 5
ECOGG -2*PDM -89 59.133 64.133 66.133 72.067 71.067 74.400 67.822 1.373 3 0.978 2
FCOGG -2*LGG -46 64.000 65.600 65.600 72.667 79.133 73.400 70.067 2.168 5 1.010 1
GCOGG -2*LGG -41 61.600 66.200 65.067 74.067 77.567 69.333 68.972 9.731 10 0.909 6
HCOGG -2*COGG -2 63.833 65.133 60.467 68.000 71.933 80.667 68.339 18.847 12 1.055 4
ICOGG -2*ML -26 62.300 65.733 67.200 72.467 74.300 73.800 69.300 -2.098 4 0.878 8
JCOGG -2*PUSA -1 62.267 65.200 69.267 73.467 82.500 79.467 72.028 -0.817 2 1.418 13
KCOGG -2*RMG -27 62.333 60.667 72.867 66.133 74.867 84.467 70.222 34.656 13 1.281 12
LCOGG -2*PDM -89 64.300 62.100 73.600 71.267 74.533 78.633 70.739 11.493 11 0.968 3
MML -267 63.533 62.133 63.867 74.533 73.067 69.600 67.789 7.749 9 0.805 10
Environmental Index -6.911 -4.634 -2.644 2.174 6.030 5.984
Mean 62.110 64.387 66.377 71.195 75.051 75.005
C. V. 3.774 2.320 4.236 4.520 4.210 4.403
F Prob. 0.041 0.000 0.000 0.000 0.000 0.000
SE of Difference 1.914 1.220 2.296 2.627 2.580 2.697
CD 95% 3.950 2.517 4.738 5.422 5.325 5.565
CD 99% 5.353 3.411 6.421 7.348 7.216 7.542

Estimation of Mean and Stability Parameters
GenotypesPlant Height cmDays to FloweringDays to MaturityFlag Leaf Area cmý
m Meanbis²dim Meanbis²dim Meanbis²dim Meanbis²di
1COGG -2 76.438 1.21 12.03 67.244 0.85 -0.27 112.000 0.41 1.45 30.579 1.21 9.04
2COGG -2*ML -267 75.341 0.74 3.29 69.722 1.12 4.35 113.778 0.76 -2.45 30.109 1.22 15.88
3COGG -2*PUSA -1 76.114 1.65 -3.09 66.128 0.80 4.06 112.633 1.03 7.09 29.576 0.68 22.05
4COGG -2*RMG -27 76.209 3.32 10.33 68.900 0.92 7.09 113.411 1.24 4.02 31.107 0.79 -2.98
5COGG -2*PDM -89 75.792 1.32 9.42 67.822 0.98 1.37 113.000 1.20 1.62 30.609 1.20 4.83
6COGG -2*LGG -46 73.075 -0.86 4.01 70.067 1.01 2.17 113.967 0.80 3.76 31.041 1.09 9.67
7COGG -2*LGG -41 74.022 1.87 8.00 68.972 0.91 9.73 113.178 0.79 8.94 31.469 0.51 -2.67
8COGG -2*COGG -2 75.317 0.42 8.10 68.339 1.05 18.85 113.528 1.27 17.17 31.117 1.59 8.73
9COGG -2*ML -26 72.637 0.74 16.16 69.300 0.88 -2.10 115.672 1.61 0.32 34.992 1.55 -0.47
10COGG -2*PUSA -1 71.677 0.35 15.93 72.028 1.42 -0.82 114.256 1.14 -0.28 32.878 1.32 2.65
11COGG -2*RMG -27 75.689 0.61 24.08 70.222 1.28 34.66 114.056 1.09 21.15 26.994 0.54 8.83
12COGG -2*PDM -89 76.479 1.08 14.15 70.739 0.97 11.49 113.022 1.01 10.46 27.298 0.59 8.41
13ML -267 78.508 0.56 -0.05 67.789 0.81 7.75 112.378 0.64 3.50 29.283 0.71 8.15
Population Mean 75.177 69.021 113.452 30.542
Stability Graph Selection Graph Transformation Plot
 


Stability Anova (Summary)
PlantDays toDays toFlag Leaf
DFHeight cm FloweringMaturity Area cmý
Rep within Env.12 15.918 7.103 5.347 14.230
Varieties12 20.734 15.031 5.357 26.420 *
Env.+ (Var.* Env.)65 18.971 39.978 *** 18.306 ** 37.561 ***
Environments5 48.337 * 398.115 *** 130.909 *** 311.923 ***
Var.* Env.60 16.524 10.134 8.923 14.698
Environments (Lin.)1 241.684 *** 1990.576 *** 654.543 *** 1559.614 ***
Var.* Env.(Lin.)12 17.675 5.105 4.975 17.509
Pooled Deviation52 14.987 *** 10.515 *** 9.147 *** 12.918 ***
Pooled Error144 4.714 2.604 3.068 5.133
Total77 19.246 36.090 16.288 35.825